A manga called The Otome Heroine’s Fight for Survival has one published volume so far, and can be interpreted as a hijacked isekai. The protagonist, a 7-year-old girl named Alicia, is actually indigenous to the otome game where the manga takes place. This is similar to manhwa like I Stole The Heroine’s First Love, except she is a separate entity who becomes self-aware that she’s the heroine of a digital story when the memories of a person who was actually isekai’d into the otome get forced into her mind.
Incredibly unique on its own, The Otome Heroine’s Fight for Survival, created by Harunohi Biyori and artist Kobato Wakasa, thankfully builds upon this unconventional setup by twisting the isekai’s many well-known tropes to differentiate itself further. For example, these memories forced into Alicia’s mind are treated like a reincarnated character who learns of their past life, usually after receiving a blow to the head.
This is also the case for the manga’s other obvious difference from the genre – the heroine adopts certain actions that are usually attributed to Isekai’d villainesses. However, in what becomes characteristic of the manga rather quickly, The Otome Heroine’s Fight for Survival provides some highly creative explanations that more than adequately justify them, since they relate to the unique premise.
Giving a Justifiable Reason Why the Heroine Became a Villainess
The protagonist becomes self-aware, deepening the story
Much like the highly unconventional and similarly titled How To Survive In a Romance Fantasy manhwa, Alicia decides to reject her role as the heroine much like a villainess who is doomed to experience an unfortunate fate. However, Alicia’s identity fully explains why she would react this way. Even better, the unique situation involving the unnamed isekai’d character also causes other deterministic theories to enter Alicia’s mind as she tries to gain a thorough understanding of her current plight. This naturally lends to Alicia eventually grappling with philosophical questions pertaining to one’s identity as well.
Moreover, the manga offers a more nuanced reason why Alicia eventually chooses the first path she takes, as opposed to what her character is meant to do. The fact that it’s the next stereotypical choice after a casual life, and still acceptable from a narrative standpoint underscores the effectiveness of this nuance. She’s essentially driven by the isekai’d person’s own class. Since Alicia has the same memories, going in this direction makes sense because she technically has the experience.
A Terrifying Implication That Is Still Fascinating, Even Though It Never Happens
Still early in its story, The Otome Heroine’s Fight For Survival has way more ground to cover
In the first few chapters, Alicia has yet to meet the otome game’s villainess, but based on past precedent, readers can expect that her actions will undoubtedly be fueled by her unique situation. These early installments also introduce a compelling prospect that later chapters will undoubtedly explore at some point. It’s assumed that how the isekai’d character’s memories transfer into Alicia’s mind could possibly be replicated. This creates the possibility that Alicia might – voluntarily or otherwise – experience the phenomenon again, adding more complications to an already complex story line.
Regardless, it’s still intriguing how the unnamed isekai’d character is portrayed in the opening chapter. Even though she isn’t a major character and may not return again, the implications alone that she could have been the protagonist are fascinating because, had she been successful, she would have been a true villainess in the body of the heroine. The fact this hasn’t happened and is still worth discussing further underscores just how innovative The Otome Heroine’s Fight for Survival is in the isekai genre and beyond.
The Otome Heroine’s Fight for Survival is available on J-Novel Club.
Read Now
