Below Deck: 10 Bosuns Who Will Never Return To The Franchise (Is My Opinion The Same As Yours?)

Below Deck has featured dozens of Bosuns since 2013, including a few who will never return to the series. The franchise relies on capable crew members who can handle the responsibilities of a luxury yacht. However, some roles are often more important than others. One of the most important parts of Below Deck is the Chief Stew. These crew members are often responsible for handling the team of junior Stews and making every guest feel comfortable. Their duties are to ensure the charter guests get everything they ask for.

Over the last 11 years, only a few Chief Stews have stood out the most. That includes Kate Chastain, who debuted on Below Deck season 2 and continued to be part of the series until season 7. Bosuns are also incredibly valuable to any super yacht. However, some of the iconic Below Deck Bosuns may never return to the franchise again.

10
Aleks Taldykin

Below Deck Season 1

Aleks Taldykin, who served as a Bosun in Below Deck season 1, was a great crew member. Unfortunately, he never returned to the show for several reasons. One of the main reasons behind his departure was his seniority. He was more of a Captain, and it wouldn’t have made sense for him to serve as a Bosun again.

9
Chandler Brooks

Below Deck Season 6

Chandler Brooks was on Below Deck season 6, where he worked with Captain Lee Rosbach and handled the deckhand team that included Ross Inia, Ashton Pienaar, Rhylee Gerber, and Tyler Rowland. Unfortunately, he was terrible at leading either of the Deckhands and couldn’t help the crew. Captain Lee finally had enough of Chandler’s incompetence in episode 9 and fired him. There’s no chance the producers will allow him to be part of Below Deck again. The former Bosun must continue his yachting journey away from the small screen.

8
Conrad Empson

Below Deck Med Season 3

Conrad Empson appeared on Below Deck Med season 3. He was a great Bosun but created unnecessary drama, especially his relationship issues with Chief Stew Hannah. The whole situation became so bad that he skipped his Prague trip. The former Bosun will now never return to the show because he decided to leave the yachting industry for good. He also found a new partner and launched a new business.

7
Kelley Johnson

Below Deck Seasons 2 & 4

Kelley Johnson was on Below Deck seasons 2 and 4. He was a good addition to the show and fulfilled his duties by handling his teams well. Unfortunately, Kelley will likely never return to Below Deck due to his personal life and new career. According to the latest reports, the former Bosun is now interested in photography and videography. He is also married and has other personal obligations. Besides, Kelley is a Captain and will probably never opt for the role of a Bosun again.

6
Paget Berry

Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 1

Paget Berry has confirmed that he’d never rejoin Below Deck. The Below Deck Sailing Yacht’s Bosun, or Chief Officer, initially enjoyed being on the show. However, he has since moved on and no longer considers it worthy of his time. A few months ago, a fan asked Paget if he’d ever return to Below Deck again and got a straightforward answer. Paget doesn’t want to be involved in the reality TV aspect of the show.

5
Eddie Lucas

Below Deck Seasons 1-3, 8-9

Eddie Lucas will likely never return to Below Deck after he called out the network on social media. He was part of numerous Below Deck seasons; however, he didn’t feel like Bravo was paying him enough and complained about it online. Eddie tried to expose the network and act like a solo warrior. He failed to realize that he was simply not above the show. The former Bosun will never return to Below Deck because Bravo will never hire him back.

4
Raygan Tyler

Below Deck Med Season 7

Raygan Tyler will never return to the series again because of his terrible run in Below Deck Med season 7. She was part of only five episodes in 2022 before Captain Sandy let him go. Her dismissal was due to her inability to perform her job, almost causing the yacht to sink. Raygan made many mistakes in the first four episodes. However, the final straw happened when she was helping Captain Sandy dock the boat and incorrectly reported three meters when the distance was less than half a meter. Sandy had to immediately let her go.

3
Ashton Pienaar

Below Deck 6-7

Ashton Pienaar from Below Deck seasons 6 and 7 wasn’t a terrible Bosun, but he was rude and had a problematic attitude towards other women on the yacht. Ashton was accused of being sexist for lashing out at Chief Stew Kate and mistreating Deckhand Rhylee. He lacked the basic decency to treat all crew members with respect. While Ashton gained some sympathy after an onboard accident, no one seems to want him back on Below Deck again.

2
Ruan Irving

Below Deck Med Season 8

Ruan Irving will also never return to the Below Deck franchise. However, the reason for his exit is completely different from everyone else’s. Unlike most Bosuns on this list, Ruan is the only one Captain Sandy fired for forging documents. The former Bosun had brought fake documents to get himself a role on the show. Regardless of whether he had the skills to do the job, it was still too risky for Captain Sandy to let him stay on board. Therefore, she fired him in episode 1, shortening his Below Deck appearance. Producers will likely never cast Ruan again.

1
Luke Jones

Below Deck Down Under Season 2

When Below Deck Down Under returned in 2023, it stood out for its several firings. One exit was from former Bosun Luke Jones, who crossed the line when he got naked and forced himself into bed with Stew Margot Sisson. Luke’s sexual misconduct was inappropriate and simply unacceptable. Captain Jason Chambers immediately fired him and removed him from the boat. Luke has no chance of returning to the Below Deck franchise again.