Developing over four seasons, Tom Clancy’s Jack Ryan offered the most detailed adaptation of the CIA analyst’s story to the screen, giving a nuanced portrayal that worked better than the other Jack Ryan iterations from 1990 onwards. Picking up at the beginning of Jack (John Krasinski) and James Greer’s (Wendell Pierce) work relationship, Jack Ryan season 1 began outlining the various interacting agents that Amazon Prime Video’s Jack Ryan would have met over the course of four seasons. Like some of the previous Jack Ryan iterations, Amazon’s Jack Ryan showed the CIA analyst at the beginning of his work on the ground, albeit involving many more characters’ stories.
With Amazon’s Jack Ryan’s medium being a TV show of multiple seasons, it managed to depict a more exhaustive picture of the CIA analyst, one that showed his growth as an operative. Previous iterations couldn’t do this as they rarely included sequels. Indeed, apart from Harrison Ford’s Jack Ryan appearing in both Clear and Present Danger and Patriot Games, all the other versions of the character only got one film each to flesh out their stories, which often proved to be not enough, especially as the challenges involved almost non-stop action. All these factors and more contribute to making Amazon’s Jack Ryan the best portrayal of Tom Clancy’s hero.
Related: Where Was Jack Ryan Filmed? All Seasons Filming Locations Explained
8 John Krasinski’s Jack Ryan Uses An Identifiable Dry Humor
Between James Greer consistently using the “bright boy” moniker for Jack in Jack Ryan season 1 and the ever-present banter when Jack and Mike November (Michael Kelly) are together, Amazon’s Jack Ryan uses a subtle, dry humor that characterizes its four seasons. Whether it’s taking a jab at Mike’s new non-governmental job, or commenting on his “super sky” skills, Jack’s relationship with his coworkers always involves some sort of banter, which lightens up the impossibly high stakes of their risky missions. Unlike all the other versions of Jack Ryan, who generally took all matters too seriously, Amazon’s Jack Ryan consistently cuts down the tension using dry humor.
7 John Krasinski’s Jack Ryan Has More Depth Than Any Other Iteration
Jack Ryan season 1 portrayed Jack as an inexperienced agent, which made sense as he had always been an analyst. However, it also made a big deal over James Greer teaching Jack to accept sometimes making deals with morally corrupt assets if that helped their ultimate goal. While Jack always spoke truth to power throughout Jack Ryan’s four seasons, he also had time to grow, something other versions of Jack Ryan never had in movies.
Ben Affleck’s and Chris Pine’s Jack Ryan were on their first mission, and while one got to the solution always too late, the other was bright but didn’t have time to show how he got better. Alec Baldwin’s Jack Ryan proved analytical and up to the task against Marko Ramius (Sean Connery), but his perspective never changed throughout The Hunt For Red October, and he had little time to grow with everything happening over one mission. Harrison Ford’s Jack Ryan had the chance to appear in more than one film, which could have helped portray a multifaceted protagonist, but besides showing an emotionally intelligent Jack, neither film showed his progress.
6 The TV Series Format Avoids Rushing Jack Ryan’s Character Development
The TV format of Amazon’s Jack Ryan not only helped with building fully-fledged characters but also with the action not feeling too rushed. Whether Jack ran from his government, to prove a point or to catch a terrorist, the TV show helped divide investigations and death-defying action sequences more evenly, making Jack’s conclusions feel reasonable and well-thought-out rather than something that magically appeared in the analyst’s mind. Most Jack Ryan movies packed too much action and not enough analysis, and especially with Ben Affleck’s and Harrison Ford’s versions, they seemed to mindlessly react to the challenges rather than analyze them beforehand.
Related: Which Version Of Jack Ryan Is The Smartest?
5 John Krasinski’s Jack Ryan Is Improved By The TV Show’s Ensemble
Having the time to do so, Amazon’s Jack Ryan thoroughly developed all the characters surrounding Jack. This could be seen also with James Greer, whose personal life is delved into in all of Jack Ryan’s four seasons, while in both Harrison Ford’s and Alec Baldwin’s versions, he is only developed as someone Jack looked to rather than a fully-fledged character. As seasons went on, Amazon’s Jack Ryan introduced Mike November, building a budding friendship between him and Jack, and Elizabeth Wright (Betty Gabriel), who often balanced Jack’s more impulsive plays. All the other Jack Ryan versions never had the ensemble that Jack could count on in Amazon’s Jack Ryan.
4 Krasinski’s Jack Ryan Faces Better Developed Threats Than Ben Affleck’s
Despite proving perceptive and emotionally intelligent, Ben Affleck’s Jack Ryan always got to the solution late, up to the point of the nuclear bomb going off and killing thousands. In The Sum of All Fears, Jack must stop nuclear war, but this issue is too big of a challenge to tackle, making his success seem particularly unrealistic and somewhat rushed. With the multiple challenges John Krasinski’s Jack faced in Jack Ryan seasons 1 through 4, he managed to go at them step by step, and if there were one or more confrontations, they always seemed balanced and not unreasonably extreme for him to solve.
3 John Krasinski’s Version Is Jack Ryan At His Most Competent
While both Alec Baldwin’s and Harrison Ford’s Jack Ryan versions were further in their career than Krasinski’s, Pine’s, or Affleck’s, their exceptionality wasn’t comprehensive. Indeed, while Baldwin’s Jack was analytical and smart, having deep knowledge of his potential asset and faith that he read the challenge in the correct way, he didn’t have a chance to prove more than that. Similarly, Harrison Ford’s Jack Ryan was clearly emotionally intelligent, and especially quick-thinking in Clear and Present Danger, but was also quick to react recklessly.
Amazon’s Jack Ryan instead showed Jack at his most competent. Not only did Jack have room to improve from Jack Ryan season 1 to 4, but the insight into his biggest regret as a Marine showed what he saw as his worst mistake and how much better he got as an operative. Throughout Jack Ryan’s four seasons, Jack learned not to put others in danger and not to let emotions rule his reactions. The overall improvement of Jack even made Amazon’s Jack Ryan season 4’s ending the best possible for him, as it was the most logical step for him, having learned all that he could.
2 Krasinski’s Version Of Jack Ryan Has The Least Black & White Perspective
Jack Ryan season 1, episode 6 had James Greer teach Jack an important lesson by having him pay Tony for his services, despite Jack abhorring having to trust him because he was a criminal. However, throughout Jack Ryan‘s four seasons, Jack learned to focus on the mission at hand without seeing everything so black and white. Indeed, Jack Ryan season 3, episode 2 had even Jack trust Tony again, and he did so on his own and with less opposition than in season 1, proving that he could put the mission first without seeing that interaction as compromising his morals.
Related: Jack Ryan Season 5: Why It’s Not Happening & Everything We Know
1 Jack & Cathy Had A More Detailed Relationship (When She Was There)
Cathy was ostensibly absent from Jack Ryan seasons 2 and 3, but when she re-entered the scene, not only was she more developed as a character in her own right but even her relationship with Jack was more detailed. Cathy was only viewed as Jack’s wife in Harrison Ford’s and Alec Baldwin’s versions, and while Chris Pine’s Jack Ryan had a more present and headstrong Cathy, Amazon’s Jack Ryan is still the version that focuses more on Cathy as a character. In the end, Cathy even proves fundamental for the mission, establishing the character in Tom Clancy’s Jack Ryan season 4 as the best version of Cathy in the franchise.
