Warning! Contains Spoilers For Batman #147!

The Joker has always been a terrifying villain because of the way he attacks people’s moral centers while trying to prove that anyone could become a twisted monster just like him — if they only had one bad day. But a new bit of information calls into question whether or not the Joker truly believes this.

Readers can see the shocking origin of the Joker’s philosophy in the story “Show the World” by Chip Zdarsky and Miguel Medonca from Batman #147. In this backup, Dr. Captio, the new warden of Zur-En-Arrh’s Arkham Asylum, is training with the Riddler and remarks that it’s easy to push people down a dark path, that all it takes is “one bad day.”

While this seems like a throwaway line, it actually has huge ramifications for the Joker’s philosophy. In fact, the Joker and Dr. Captio have a deep history together, with Capito being the one who actually trained the Joker in everything he knows how to do.

The Joker’s “One Bad Day” Ideology Isn’t Even His Own

Daniel Captio Reveals All

One of the Joker’s defining characteristics is his belief that only one bad day can drive anyone to madness. This idea is a compelling philosophy, especially considering that Batman famously had one bad day and it completely changed his life. Many would say it drove him insane, considering he dresses up like a bat and punches criminals in the night. The “One Bad Day” philosophy has stuck to Joker’s character for decades. Even though it’s been proven wrong before, it’s still been a major component of his character since its introduction, but now it seems “One Bad Day” wasn’t even the Joker’s idea.

It was revealed during The Joker Year One (by Zdarsky, Giuseppe Camuncoli, and Andrea Sorrentino) that Joker was trained by Dr. Captio, who molded the Joker into the brutal killer he is today. Originally, after the Joker’s “one bad day,” he didn’t take on a new philosophy and become a supervillain. He was actually terrified of Batman and seemingly completely harmless. It was only after Daniel Captio found the Joker and began training him that he turned into the dangerous supervillain that readers know today. This seems to even extend to Joker’s philosophy, as the fact that Captio uses the exact same wording is a major red flag.

Joker’s Entire World View Was Likely Created By Dr. Captio

Joker’s Mind Was Built by Captio, Including His Twisted Philosophy

Dr. Daniel Captio is an expert on the human mind and has helped plenty of people create new personas and ideologies. It’s entirely because of Captio that Batman created the personality of Zur-En-Arrh. He also helped the Joker create the three different personas that he has used throughout his career as a criminal. It’s not a leap to assume that Captio also likely implanted the idea of “one bad day” into the Joker. Captio created the Joker to be the perfect threat to Batman, and there’s no better way than twisting Batman’s own personal tragedy of one bad day into the Joker’s main philosophy.

Batman #147 is available now from DC Comics!