With Aesha Scott seemingly exiting Below Deck Down Under, several stews could replace her as Chief Stew. She pioneered the franchise as Captain Jason Chambers’ Chief Stew during seasons 1 and 2 of the Below Deck spin-off. Aesha and Captain Jason had an undeniable chemistry, working together seamlessly while operating successful charters on the two yachts they worked on. Before her stint on Below Deck Down Under, Aesha appeared in Below Deck Med seasons 4 and 5 as a stew under Hannah Ferrier. She quickly became a fan-favorite crew member, beloved for her bubbly personality.

Her prosperity as a stew on Below Deck Med led to her becoming the Chief Stew of Below Deck Down Under. However, she’s returning to her roots to work as Captain Sandy Yawn’s Chief Stew on Below Deck Med season 9. Because she’s working on the Mustique again, it’s unclear if she’ll serve as Jason Chamber’s Chief Stew again for season 3. Aesha belongs on Below Deck Down Under, but her exit from the franchise may be inevitably coming, and the show must go on with a new Chief Stew whether fans like it or not.

8

Tumi Mhlongo

Below Deck Down Under Season 1 & Below Deck Med Season 8

Tumi Mhlongo would be the natural replacement for Aesha on Below Deck Down Under. Her first appearance in the franchise was in the Australian-based yachting series. She worked as Aesha’s second stew during Below Deck Down Under season 1, where she excelled. After a great season as a second stew, she was promoted to Captain Sandy’s Chief Stew during Below Deck Med season 8. Her time on Below Deck Down Under was arguably much better than Below Deck Med. She had a season-long fight with Natalya Scudder that disrupted their charters and made the show unbearable at times.

Since Below Deck Med season 8, Tumi and Natalya have ended their feud. They got off on the wrong foot after Kyle Viljoen meddled in their relationship. At times, Tumi handled things poorly as Chief Stew. However, after going through a charter season as hectic as that one, she could exceed in Below Deck Down Under season 3. It’s where she got her start on the Below Deck franchise. With Aesha making the switch back to Below Deck Med, they could trade roles and have Tumi take over her position as Captain Jason’s Chief Stew.

7

Julia d’Albert Pusey

Below Deck Mediterranean Season 1

Julia d’Albert Pusey was Hannah’s second stew in the first season of Below Deck Med. She helped pioneer the spin-off that has gone on to become a smash hit. Julia had a positive attitude during Below Deck Med season 1, which is essential for success as a stew in the yachting industry. She went into the season with nearly eight years of experience, making her well-qualified for the job. Julia has gone on to pursue different avenues of business, but Below Deck Down Under would benefit from having her as Captain Jason’s Chief Stew.

6

Xandi Olivier

Below Deck Season 11

Xandi Olivier was a great second stew under Fraser Olender during Below Deck season 11. Working with the experienced Chief Stew, Fraser took a natural liking towards Xandi for her hardworking nature. She didn’t complain when he gave her jobs and knew how to do her job correctly. At times, the interior team on Below Deck season 11 clashed, but Xandi was rarely in the drama. She butted heads with Barbie Pascual at times but did a good job at resolving every conflict she was caught up in.

5

Fraser Olender

Below Deck Season 9-11

Fraser has the experience needed to take on Aesha’s job in Below Deck Down Under. He first joined the franchise during Below Deck season 9. Fraser did such a great job working as a stew during his first season that he was immediately asked back as the Chief Stew for Below Deck season 10. He made franchise history by becoming the first male Chief Stew on the show and subsequently came back for the show’s eleventh season. He possesses a witty charm that the interior team head needs to appeal to all the crew members and charter guests.

Throughout Below Deck season 11, Fraser gained more experience. He made mistakes along the way, letting his feelings about some of his stews impact his professional decisions. He worked well alongside Captain Kerry Titheradge, who guided Fraser in the right direction. No Chief Stew is completely perfect, but Fraser’s ability to appeal to the guests and right his wrongs makes him the perfect option for Chief Stew of Below Deck Down Under season 3.

4

Katie Flood

Below Deck Med Season 6

Heading into Below Deck Med season 6, Katie Flood had big shoes to fill. She preceded Captain Sandy’s longtime Chief Stew, Hannah Ferrier. Hannah is one of the most beloved Below Deck personalities ever, so it was unclear who would replace her on the show. However, Katie served as the best replacement for Hannah when she appeared in Below Deck Med season 6. She had a lot of experience and excelled at the head of the interior team. She’s only had one season in the franchise, but that doesn’t mean she couldn’t return for Below Deck Down Under season 3.

3

Jaimee Neale

Below Deck Down Under Season 2

Jaimee Neale was one of Aesha’s stews on Below Deck Down Under season 2. She joined the series to replace controversial crew member, Laura Bileskalne. Aesha’s second stew, Laura, was fired after justifying Luke Jones’ sexual misconduct towards Margot Sisson after a night of drinking. Margot explained that Luke had entered her bunk naked and tried to get in bed with her and the producers had to step in and get in and out of the room. Aesha reported the incident to Captain Jason, and he was fired immediately.

Instead of feeling sympathy for Margot, Laura was more upset that Luke had left the boat. Captain Jason then fired Laura for her stance on the situation. It was one of the worst moments in Below Deck history. When Jaimee stepped in, she became a lovable personality on the show. She has previous experience working for Captain Jason, meaning she knows how he likes things to run on board. For this reason, she should step up as Chief Stew on Below Deck Down Under season 3.

2

Barbie Pascual

Below Deck Season 11

Barbie would be TV gold as the Chief Stew for Below Deck Down Under. Entering the franchise on Below Deck season 11, she had quite the journey as one of Fraser’s stews. Barbie had much to learn during the season and started to be quite combative and dismissive of her superiors. She disrespected Chief Stew Fraser and his second stew, Xandi, quite a few times. Barbie and Fraser fought during the first half of Below Deck season 11, and her attitude almost got her fired. However, Captain Terry recognized that she was a hardworking stew, and opted to keep her around.

After Captain Terry had a talk with Fraser and urged him to make amends with Barbie, her attitude shifted in Below Deck season 11. She admitted that she looked up to her Chief Stew and wanted to perform well as one of his stews. Her vulnerability and honesty served her extremely well and allowed her to get closer to Fraser. Barbie learned a lot during Below Deck season 11 and could apply her newfound knowledge as Chief Stew on Below Deck Down Under.

1

Daisy Kelliher

Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 2-4

Daisy Kelliher is one of the best Below Deck Chief Stews to appear in the franchise. She’s the longtime Chief Stew on Below Deck Sailing Yacht, joining the series during season 2 and staying through season 4. Daisy is known for her manners and service. She is a genuine person who comes off as endearing. Unlike other Chief Stews in past seasons, Daisy cares about her crew and makes sure to set her team up for success. Jenna MacGillivray was a good Chief Stew during Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 1, and Daisy was the best option to replace her.

Because Aesha is joining Below Deck Med, Captain Jason may have to hire her replacement for Below Deck Down Under. It will be devastating if the Chief Stew doesn’t return for the spin-off’s third season. However, Captain Jason has a large pool of potential candidates that would work great for him on Below Deck Down Under.