In today’s superhero landscape, we almost exclusively watch a clash of titans. Franchising has taken priority, with shared universes and spin-offs. As Marvel continues to regain characters, many superheroes will fall into a singular brand. And the hurried DCEU has mainly accumulated divisive films, although it’s found an occasional winning streak.
Rather than cast a dark tone over the entirety of their roster, the DCEU has adjusted to fit characters individually. And every success is squeezed for more, even including an elaboration on “The Trench” from James Wan’s Aquaman. So, it can be easy to forget the intriguing films outside these massive worlds, which vie for ultimate longevity. Brace for a lot of Batman and subjectivity, though.
Constantine
This supernatural detective story is quite underrated, a brisk exercise in action-horror that feels stronger in hindsight. The old-school investigation tropes blend well with the religious iconography and mythology. The character was partly invented by Alan Moore after all, resulting in an antihero with a heart. The cinematography is positively gorgeous, and feeds the overall tone. This is an unexpectedly nuanced film between CGI bouts, an approach that arguably wouldn’t be tolerated today. At least, aside from A-listers like Wolverine or the Joker. With Keanu back on everyone’s wishlist, hopefully viewers will revisit this underrated gem. It boasts an all-star cast, even the MCU’s Ancient One.
The Dark Knight Rises
Conversely, it may be blasphemous to say that this film was probably overrated. Particularly following such a gargantuan success, and Heath Ledger’s legendary performance. That predecessor only evolved and improved Christopher Nolan’s series, cementing itself as the definitive superhero film. Thematically, the trilogy closes as it should. And conceptually, even the plot feels like a natural progression, testing an aged Batman against a young and powerful terrorist. Bruce’s past catches up with him, but he ultimately finds peace while his legacy carries on. Yet the journey there is surprisingly muddled, winding and overlong, stymied by its own monumental ambition.
Watchmen
Maintaining a strict fidelity to the source material, the few changes felt born of necessity. The meta plot of the monster would not have translated well into cinema. And yes, perhaps Alan Moore’s work should stay on the page. But thanks to powerful casting, this is probably still the best interpretation that one could have hoped for. Director Zack Snyder thrives in stories that are larger than life.
The grandiose lore and themes, explored through sweeping emotions, are already gripping. If nothing else, the film certainly introduced many casual viewers to comics, including those which may not have otherwise indulged. Snyder’s highly stylized adaptation is brimming with sincere enthusiasm, and no one can argue with Jackie Earle Haley’s Rorschach.
Batman: Mask Of The Phantasm
Unexpectedly timeless, the original animated series that inspired this theatrically released film was an instant hit. Distinctly influenced by the darker vision Burton introduced, this series displayed an even deeper understanding of Batman’s world. The characters are richly developed, with intriguing relationships and morals, while constantly maintaining fun entertainment. The 90’s aesthetic of animation has a special potency, of personality and love that is rarely achieved. Further, the cast has also transcended the expectations of a Saturday morning cartoon. Kevin Conroy still returns to this beloved character, today. And so often, even Mark Hamill of Star Wars is equally known for the Joker.
Batman (1989)
Tim Burton’s indelible signatures transformed Batman from Adam West’s endearing fun into a darker vision. At least, for the time. Some elements of the film haven’t dated especially well, such as Joker’s extensive boombox dance. However, Burton’s natural quirks are simply conducive to blend Gothic nightmare and cartoonish wackiness. The performances are certainly iconic, particularly including Jack Nicholson’s subdued mania. He’s one of the few people that can sell insanity without losing a threatening bite. And Danny Elfman’s music is more than enough for any critic to lose their crossed arms. This is a comic book world that earns its nostalgia and perpetual fandom.
Batman Begins
During the burgeoning years of the superhero craze, Nolan’s determination to ground Batman in stern verisimilitude was a revelation. The X-Men films had taken themselves seriously enough, but this was another step altogether. While the “voice” Bruce puts on may not have aged well, at all, everything else has. Nolan restored the detective skills to Batman’s reputation, and the story is remarkably character-driven.
Nolan’s deeper interest in exploring broad yet intimate themes allowed greater audience investment. The nature of vigilante justice and its ethics is intriguing, and Batman’s evolution is plausibly earned. The performances, imagery, and music are all compelling and innovative, a perfect storm of artistry that strongly influenced its peers.
Joker
With so many blatant influences, it’s hard to argue with points for innovation. The film loosely updates Taxi Driver with today’s socio-political issues. However, the movie is predominantly fueled by Joaquin Phoenix’s performance, both stunning and haunting. The tragedy of Arthur’s life innately generates empathy, particularly with the film’s approach to mental illness. And the Joker’s surrounding world is so profoundly awful, the movie practically paints Joker as a vigilante not unlike Batman himself. Phoenix and company have created a heartbreaking character, who is nearly pardoned for his villainous antics. He is subjected to lies, social oppression and mistreatment, resulting in a spellbinding character study of descent.
Superman: The Movie
This quintessential adventure proved that superheroes are a viable blockbuster experience. The studios invoked a massive showcase of talent. The Godfather’s Mario Puzo contributed to the screenplay, the impeccable Marlon Brando and Gene Hackman show up, and John Williams’ music soars. Newcomer Christopher Reeve was perfectly cast as the titular hero, and many of the special effects remain convincing enough today.
The story captures the essence of Superman—his heart, strengths, and flaws. The first half is unexpectedly nuanced, exploring young Clark’s adopted life, mentored with love. But he also faces bullying and unavoidable loss. The latter half is a full-blown comic book movie, with wacky villains, romance and disaster rescues. It’s a structurally robust story with iconography and themes that will perpetually inspire.
V For Vendetta
This film single-handedly popularized the Guy Fawkes mask. Translating the politics of the source material where needed, the story’s exploration of fascism and anarchy are innately timeless. The ideas are profound without preaching, and perhaps the greatest change is transforming V himself into a distinct hero. The consequences of a fascist government invite conversations about freedom, including the roles of religion, media, and even sexual orientation. And yet, for all the rumination, viewers slowly learn to love a personable V. His tortured past, humanity, and righteous motives ask audiences to forgive his questionable methods. The film wields powerful symbolism and large-scale themes, driven by exhilarating action sequences. It transcends the expectations of any comic book, and should invite everyone to read the invaluable source material.
The Dark Knight
There’s little praise left to give Christopher Nolan’s monumental sequel, endlessly quotable and crucially accessible. Heath Ledger’s genius Joker performance lent the film a beautiful escalation and wit. His mysterious nature, dark comedy and unpredictable wrath are all equally gripping. He drives the film’s plot and themes alike, challenging Bruce and the city to face their darkest limits. Bruce’s personal life suffers, and he ultimately resorts to illegal surveillance. The film is Christopher Nolan’s ultimate indulgence, which results in a wider examination of society, fate, vigilante morality, and human weaknesses. Whatever flaws hindsight has produced, there’s no denying Nolan’s unapologetic ambition, brilliant artistry, and fascinating characterization.
